Story by: Akira Toriyama | Art by: Toyotarou
The eighth DRAGON BALL SUPER installments opens with a focus on Freeza battling Caulifla and Kale, two of the Saiyans from Universe 6. Caulifla, having learned from Cabba how to go Super Saiyan, puts up a strong showing against Freeza, until the villain changes to his ultimate form -- Golden Freeza. Interestingly, however the RESURRECTION "F" storyline went in the manga (remember, we have no idea since it was inexplicably skipped with the weak reason that readers should just go watch the movie instead), it's clear that it was at least partially different from the anime -- because while Freeza revealed his Golden form in both the movie and TV versions of that story, here everyone (including Goku) is surprised by it.
When Golden Freeza gains the upper hand on Caulifla, her friend Kale steps in, revealing a "new" Super Saiyan form no one has ever seen. This is, famously, the first canon version of the "Legendary Super Saiyan" power-up achieved by Broly in the 1990s DBZ movies -- all of which existed outside of the official continuity. Kale begins beating on Freeza to the point that Goku has to step in and save him, and the pair briefly battles her together until she zips away from the fight on a rampage.
Kale singel-handedly completes the elimnation of four universes, but her mindlessness takes a toll and Universe 11's Pride Troopers work together to subdue her. Caulifla, meanwhile, reveals that she stole the Potara earrings from her universe's Kaioshin. When Champa sees this from the stands, he orders Caulfila to put on one earring and get the other on Kale. With the help (and sacrifice) of Cabba, an earring is placed on Kale, and Caulifla dons the other. The pair fuses into a being called Kefla, who promptly wipes out the majority of the Pride Troopers -- then Gohan steps in to challenge her, resulting in a double knockout which eliminates Gohan and sees Universe 6 wiped out. Gohan reveals during their fight that he no longer goes Super Saiyan, which seems to be a reference to his so-called "Mystic" form power-up from late in DRAGON BALL Z. Though interestingly, the manga has him state that he has stopped relying on his "Saiyan blood" and instead has chosen to "keep evolving as a human." I'm probably reading between the lines too much -- however he chooses to frame his evolution as a fighter, he is and always will be half-Saiyan and have the inherent benefits of that heritage -- but in any case, this feels like Toriyama and/or Toyotarou providing a "back door" for the human characters to continue to fight alongside the all-powerful Saiyans. Of course I doubt that will ever be the case, but you never know.
At any rate, there is a bit of good news for the humans, here. Master Roshi takes out one of the Pride Troopers, then goes into teacher mode, reminding Goku that it's not enough to simply be strong -- he must be fast, as well. Roshi then demonstrates by staging an attack on Jiren, much to everyone's surprise. Of course Jiren defeat's Roshi, knocking him out of the tournament, but not before he shows Goku that even an old-timer can evade a few of Jiren's attacks. Beerus and Whis briefly wonder if Roshi has mastered the fabled "Ultra Instinct" technique until he's defeated, but Roshi's example leads Goku to demonstrate Ultra Instinct himself, for just a moment.
This development leads Vegeta to reach a new plateau of power as well, and he engages Jiren while Goku recovers. Meanwhile, Freeza and Android 17 go up against the remaining Pride Troopers, Top and Dyspo. When Vegeta burns himself out, Goku pulls him away from Jiren, who heads off to his allies' aid. Jiren battles Freeza and 17, with 17 realizing there's only one way to win -- by self-destructing. But even this gesture isn't enough to scratch Jiren. Jiren then takes Top and Dyspo out of the fight himself, promising to win alone. Goke reattains the Ultra Instinct form, and the fight continues. This volume also contains a short little backup story set just before the torunament's start, in which Goten, Trunks, and Krillin and 18's daughter, Marron, are sent to Android 17's island to fill in for him as park rangers until his return. No sooner are the three left alone, than they're attacked by a group of Cell Juniors! The Saiyan kids hold out long enough for the Juniors to recognize their ranger patches, which leads the creatures to depart. At the same time, as they fly away from the island, 17 explains to 18 and Krillin that he found the Cell Juniors on the island years ago and tamed them to respect rangers.
The story ends with a little text box explaining that the Cell Juniors are likely the original seven created by Cell years earlier, regenerated just as Cell did, from whatever genetic material was left when they were killed by Gohan. It's a funny little story and I like it. The Androids/Cell Saga is my favorite part of DRAGON BALL Z (though I tend to favor the earlier parts more than the Cell Games themselves), so as with callbacks to classic DRAGON BALL, any callbacks to that era are always appreciated too.
At this point we're going to delve a bit into SUPER volume 9, which features the end of the tournament before moving along to new content. To sum up, Goku loses Ultra Instinct again, then teams up with Freeza to get Jiren on the defensive. But even their combined power isn't enough to stop him, and Vegeta is knocked out of the fight. Then Freeza, having survived 17's self-destruct, dramatically reappears with his Death Ball attack. In a callback to the Saiyan Saga, as Goku keeps Jiren in a hold, Freeza blasts both of them -- but Jiren deflects the attack. Freeza isn't deterred, however, and rams both Jiren and Goku out of the ring. With all three defeated, Android 17 emerges, having faked the self-destruct and planned the entire thing with Freeza, and claims victory. 17 wishes for all the destroyed universes to come back, and then everyone is sent home. Freeza is resurrected as promised by Goku (though as a gift from Beerus rather than via the Dragon Balls), and heads off into space to begin plotting anew. Then we get a bit of text telling us that the BROLY movie (which I still haven't seen for some reason) comes next in continuity, but the manga will not be adapting it. After that, we skip ahead a bit in time to post-BROLY, and we'll cover that material next week.
Though I had some complaints about it, I really like certain aspects of the manga's version of the Tournament of Power. Roshi gets more of a spotlight, Jiren is better fleshed out, and certain moments, such as Freeza's reappearance, come across way more dramatic than in the TV version. Plus, the tournament is only six chapters long in the manga, while it ran for 55 episodes (!) of the anime. I do think six chapters is a bit short -- it takes up one-and-a-half volumes of the manga in total, where most of the tournaments in the original DB ran for two volumes, as best I can recall. I guess my ideal version of the Tournament would be some sort of hybrid of both.
Lastly, I want to add that I like the idea of Freeza as a recurring foe in DRAGON BALL. It's something the series never really had before. Villains would stick around, often for some time, but -- aside from Tien, Piccolo, and Vegeta, who all eventually became good guys -- they wouldn't last beyond their respective sagas, being defnitively killed at the end of their final battles with Goku. I just hope SUPER doesn't go that route with Freeza, because a reformation doesn't suit him. He should be that one recurring foe who is always able to keep pace with Goku. That said, I wouldn't want to see him overused. He needn't be in every arc or every other arc or anything like that -- but once in a while, it will be nice to have him return with some new evil scheme.
Next week, the SUPER manga journeys into uncharted territory, moving beyond where the TV series ended!
Well Freeza remained an enemy in the Broly movie, so hopefully if Super ever returns (or if the manga gets back to him) he'll stay evil.
ReplyDeleteI'm of mixed minds about the manga version of the ToP. True, Gohan gets something to do, and Roshi dodging Jiren for a bit is fun, but the big character moments in the anime are a lot better. Roshi's got some equally good moments in the anime, Toppo's choice to embrace the power of destruction after spending long episodes going on about justice (and Vegeta's means of defeating him) is great, and Jiren and Goku's battle is far more satisfying. I admit my bias here since the scene where Goku masters Ultra Instinct is my favorite scene in any anime EVER, but the manga ToP just feels so rushed in comparison.
So now onto the post-series stuff and...I definitely have opinions on that, let me tell you.
I've been reading the Moro arc, as we'll see starting next week, and -- despite what I said above about NOT wanting Freeza to show up in every storyline -- I'm a bit surprised he's absent. A godlike being rampaging throughout the galaxy, destroying entire planets, seems like something that might catch his attention -- even if it was only presented as a brief cameo where he comments about it and then goes on with his business.
DeleteI do agree that the manga tournament feels rushed. The anime version feels too stretched out by comparison, though -- especially when you compare it with SUPER's previous storylines, which were all considerably shorter, and which in some cases might have benefitted from being longer!
I think overall I do like the anime tournament more; there are just certain bits and pieces of the manga that I prefer.
Interested to get your take on the Moro saga. So far I actually like it, but I haven't gotten beyond the part where Moro dispatches his men to Earth.
Overall I prefer the Anime. Kuririn, Tenshinhan, Roshi, and 18’s contribution (especially the latter in her unconditional love vs Ribranne’s superficial views). I prefer Gohan in the Anime. No matter the quality of the opponents, it felt like some heart was put in in developing him as a fighter. He uses his brain, controls his arrogance, and gets some good character moments (his mourning Universe 10, protecting Piccolo, etc) as well as an interesting interaction with Freeza. His sacrifice to eliminate Dyspo is a fulfillment to his resolving his ‘gets cocky/drop his guard’ issues. Gohan’s appearance in the manga felt like Toyataro was dragging his feet in using the character. Like ‘Okay I’ll have him fight Kefla, but don’t expect anything else!’ The development scenes are off panel, he suddenly gets a power increase during the fight (surprising Piccolo) and the majority of his fight with Kefla is off panel, the only action he does there is grab-stop kefla’s dive kick. I’m not against the idea of Gohan fighting kefla, but it felt rather skeletal without substance despite Kefla’s significance. There is a sliver of a plot to reconcile Goku and Gohan, but aside from Goku’s shock at seeing his son eliminated its dropped. Am I mistaken that Gohan is absent from the conclusion?
ReplyDeleteGohan is there at the conclusion in that he's sitting in the stands with everybody else, but he doesn't have any lines and you really only see him in a couple of wide-shot panels. You're right; aside from his fight with Kefla, he's basically a nonentity during the tournament. I liked him better in the anime as the "team captain". Even though Goku, Vegeta, and Freeza ignored his strategy, everybody else followed it and they all survived pretty deep into the tournament.
Delete