NOTE

Monday, January 31, 2022

INVADERS #19

"WAR COMES TO THE WILHELMSTRASSE"
Author/Editor: Roy Thomas | Illustrators/Innovators: Frank Robbins & Frank Springer
Letterer: John Costanza | Colorist: Goerge Roussos | Consulting Editor: Archie Goodwin

The Plot: Namor, the Human Torch, Toro, and Bucky, all captives of the Third Reich, are paraded through Berlin. Captain America and the Destroyer observe from hiding, until Bucky angers a Nazi guard. When the guard prepares to shoot Bucky, Cap leaps into action, and the Destroyer follows. But in the ensuing skirmish, the Destroyer is killed by a grenade blast, and Cap is captured.

The entire incident is observed from hiding by Lord Falsworth, Spitfire, Dyna-Mite, and their aide, Oskar. The quartet has come to Berlin seeking a way to restore Dyna-Mite to his normal size, and looking for Falsworth's son, Brian. When the group heads to the Nazi Institute of Science, they run across the scientist who altered Dyna-Mite and the other Crusaders, but he captures them with a trap door and some knockout gas.

The next morning, Spitfire stands alongside the other Invaders, all drugged to prevent escape, for execution. As Master Man and Warrior Woman stand before a minister to be publicly wed, Hitler orders a firing squad to finish the Invaders. But before the squad can carry out this command, Union Jack leaps into the scene.

Continuity Notes: On the first page, narration states that the first World War took place in "Earth's second decade". I, uhh... think that's a "typo". Obviously Thomas meant to say the second decade of the twentieth century, or something similar.

The secret of Dyna-Mite (and of the Destroyer) is revealed to readers at last: Lord Falsworth and Spitfire recognized Dyna-Mite as Roger Aubrey, the best friend of Brian Falsworth. Though Dyna-Mite has no memory of his life prior to the Crusaders, Falsworth explains that he and Brian went to Berlin to break bread with Hitler following British Prime Minister's historic meeting with the German Chancellor.
The Nazi scientist explains that Brian and Roger were not allowed to leave Germany, for fear they might go back on their endorsement of Chamberlain's appeasement policy. When they fought back, Brian was arrested due to his status as a nobleman, while Roger was set to be executed. But instead, he was recruited for the Crusaders, while Brian escaped his cell and became -- the Destroyer.
My Thoughts: I'm not sure what to make of the issue's credits listing the Franks, Robbins and Springer, as "Illustrators/Innovators"... Stan Lee used to use the "Innovator" credit sometimes in the sixties, and I was never quire certain what it meant. It pops up a lot in AMAZING SPIDER-MAN circa the #60s and #70s. Sometimes it went to John Romita, which I took as a way to acknowledge that he did a ton of uncredited plotting on the series, but other times you would see it for John Buscema, who occasionally did breakdowns on the series. I suppose it may simply be a precursor to when you would occasionally see the penciler credited as "storyteller" -- a way to note that the artist on a book done "Marvel-style" contributes a lot more to the story than one working from a fully-written script.

Anyway! This is a good one. An exciting action scene to open things up, the resolution (more-or-less) of a pair of mysteries -- who are Dyna-Mite and the Destroyer, and what is their reltionship to the Falsworths? -- and a fantastic cliffhanger to close things out! I mean, I'm not kidding: the final scene of this issue is easily one of the most dramatic and exciting moments we've seen from Thomas and Robbins since things began, easily trumping pretty much everything else up to this point.

In part, that may simply be because this is sort of a "positive" cliffhanger. By definition, a cliffhanger is a moment to close out a chapter in a serial with the heroes in danger, so as to bring the audience back to find out how they get out of it. And while we do have that here, with the Invaders about to be executed, the story actually ends on a dynamic shot of Union Jack dropping in on the Nazis. It's the sort of cliffhanger that's less about worrying over the fates of your heroes, and more about getting pumped up by a big reveal. It's not something you see all that often, and I love it because of that.

3 comments:

  1. You know, my memory of this story, and now your review of it, is telling me that this arc would have been a damn good place to end the book (and probably would have been where it did in modern times.) Once you build a World War II book to actually showing Hitler, since you can't actually kill him off, you just get diminishing returns. That the book continues on for more issues than it's already run kind of amazes me, because this now feels like a perfect point to end it. Of course, back then, comics ran until they died a cancellation death, and the idea of ending a series at a logical point didn't exist yet. I'd actually forgotten the book ran until nearly 1980, which really seems past its sell by date, but I do recall buying issues into the late 30s. Chalk it up to getting old.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Personally, I find the idea of using Hitler himself as a recurring antagonist in your World War II superhero comic a little wierd, and perhaps... distasteful? I mean, cameo appearances now and then, like when he christened the Red Skull in classic CAPTAIN AMERICA comics, are fine. But Hitler is a major player in both this arc and the one where Thor is warped to WWII several issues from now. And of course, in the WHAT IF? issue that ends the Invaders' saga, it's revealed (or rather reiterated based on past stories, I suppose) that the Human Torch actually killed Hitler in the Marvel Universe!

      I'm not sure what I don't like about this, other than the weirdness that comes of overtly mixing real political figures in with fictional ones. I mean, even Steve Englhart had the good sense to only hint that Nixon was the leader of the Secret Empire! I suppose there's something about Hitler that makes him a good comic book villain; his grandstanding persona sort of lends him to it. But again, knowing what he did in the real world, it's distasteful for me to see him handled that way in the comics.

      I think a better idea would've been to come up with a fictional high-ranking Nazi leader, someone who could be one of Hitler's top aides, to have these repeated run-ins with the Invaders.

      Delete
    2. The Torch killing Hitler comes from Young Men #24 which was the start of the 1950s attempted revival of the big three. The main change for What If? was to put Toro there as well - the Young Men story had moved his debut to the immediate post war years.

      The portrayal of the Nazis and specifically Hitler has changed in media over the years and IIUC a big game changer was the TV mini series "Holocaust" which came out about a year after this issue. Here we've got the older portrayal rather than the ultimate evil in human form.

      Delete