"REPERCUSSIONS"
Writer: Bob Harras | Penciler: Steve Epting | Inker: Tom Palmer
Colorists: Tom Palmber & Sarra Mossoff | Letterer: Bill Oakley
Editor: Ralph Macchio | Editor-in-Chief: Tom DeFalco
Writer: Bob Harras | Penciler: Steve Epting | Inker: Tom Palmer
Colorists: Tom Palmber & Sarra Mossoff | Letterer: Bill Oakley
Editor: Ralph Macchio | Editor-in-Chief: Tom DeFalco
The Plot: On a remote planet called Seti Tatola IV, a former Kree admiral meets with Raza and Hepzibah of the Starjammers. He convinces them to travel to Earth and kill the Black Knight as revenge for the assassination of the Supreme Intelligence. On Earth, Professor X and Cyclops of the X-Men, as well as Quicksilver and Doctor Valerie Cooper from the U.S. govenment's X-Factor, visit the Avengers. Xavier warns the group that Magneto's Acolytes are back in action, and they may be targeting Luna, daughter of Quicksilver and Crystal. Meanwhile, in space, the Starjammers elude Shi'ar patrols and set course for Earth, with Hepizabah and Raza having convinced the rest that they need to check on Carol Danvers.
Absent from the X-Men meeting is Black Knight, who skipped it for a workout session. Afterward, he heads to the roof, where he bumps into Sersi and the two witness the arrival of the Starjammer. Soon, the Avengers, their guests, and the Starjammers gather in a reception room -- but Raza slips away and sneaks up on the Black Knight, repairing the Avengers' skycar in their hangar. Raza attacks and duels the Knight, until the nursemaid Marilla enters with Luna. Raza grabs Luna and holds her hostage, until the Knight lunges at him. Raza runs the Avenger through. Seconds later, the remaining Avengers respond to the sound of battle, arriving to find Black Knight seemlingly dead.
Continuity Notes: Though there are only a handful of footnotes in this issue, there's plenty of continuity in which to bask! First up -- Raza makes reference to the nega-bomb event in AVENGERS #347. In the same scene, Raza is convinced to kill Black Knight when the Kree admiral reveals that Raza's son, sentenced to the Shi'ar slave pens when he was only five years old, is still alive. I have a faint recollection that Raza's son was mentioned in a previous appearance in X-MEN, but I'm not positive. Raza spends the rest of the issue in a moral quandary over whether he's doing the right thing, but he really wants his son back. (Hepzibah, meanwhile, always the most mercenary and pragmatic Starjammer, is happy to take the assassination assignment simply on the promise of payment -- two hundred million credits.) Professor X mentions that the X-Men first encountered the Acolytes in X-MEN #1 through 3. In the same scene, reference is made to his history with Carol Danvers -- Xavier and the X-Men took her in after she permanently lost her powers (and her emotional attachment to her life's memories) to Rogue in AVENGERS ANNUAL #10. Carol, recently recovered from her power burnout in QUASAR, asks Xavier to join her for a conversation about Lilandra's recent actions. Hercules has shaved his beard as of this issue, with no explanation as to why. As the run moves along, he will also grow his hair longer. I initially wondered if all of this was to make him look a bit more like Kevin Sorbo from the 1990s syndicated HERCULES TV series, but that show didn't start until near the end of this run -- so maybe Steve Epting just thought Herc needed a makeover for fun.
Black Knight refuses to tell Thor and Hercules why he skipped the meeting, but his inner monologue reveals that he didn't want to see Crystal and Quicksilver together, given his burgeoning feelings for the Inhuman princess. But of course he then bumps into them in the hallway during this introspection. Moments later, on the roof, Sersi displays her own affection for the Black Knight by advocating for her hedonistic lifestyle and laying an unexpected kiss upon him. After the Starjammers arrive, Cyclops takes his father, Corsair, aside to discuss the fates of his son, Nathan, and wife, Madelyne. In the same scene, Corsair suggests that Lilandra is unaware Xavier was recently crippled again. Given how easily the X-Men are shown to communicate with the Shi'ar in upcoming issues of their own series, it seems that perhaps they don't have their intergalactic commlink installed yet. Black Knight mentions that he's been repairing the skycar for the past week -- and in the previous issue, two weeks passed between its crash and when the Knight finished examining it. So it's likely been at least a month since "Galactic Storm" ended.
This issue contains a backup story, "The Butler Did It!", by John Lewandowski, Kevin Kobasic, and Ariane Lenshoek. It's an inconsequential (but funny!) tale spotlighting the enmity between Jarvis and Marilla. It is evidently set prior to this issue's main story -- and probably even prior to "Galactic Storm" -- as, at one point, it features the Avengers, including Captain America and Hercules' beard, racing off to join the INFINITY WAR. Assemble: Yet again, no use of the battlecry. ("Avengers Assemble!" count: 3 in 17 issues to date.)
My Thoughts: I've never read this issue, but being a big X-Men fan, especially of the X-Men from the early nineties era, I'm surprised to find it so steeped in X-mythology! I mean, this is apparently the place where Cyclops tells his dad what happened to Madelyne and baby Nathan, and where Professor X sees the Starjammers and Binary for the first time in years. Not to mention, this is the first hint that the Acolytes are back in action! Reading this, I assumed it was part of the lead-up to the UNCANNY X-MEN 298 - 300 storyline, the return of the Acolytes ahead of "Fatal Attractions" a couple months later, but I was shocked to find this issue is cover-dated the same month as UNCANNY #291 and X-MEN #11. Forget about "Fatal Attractions" or even it's lead-up issues -- "X-Cutioner's Song" hasn't even happened yet! So clearly Harras was planning the return of the Acolytes very well in advance. I had no idea! It's less than a year since they all "died" in X-MEN #3, and about seven months prior to their return in UNCANNY 298.
Anyway, I'm a little surprised this issue -- or at least, excerpts from it -- isn't included in any of the X-MEN books collecting this era. It may not be integral, but it does feature some nice tidbits of X-continuity. But! Believe it or not, this is actually an AVENGERS issue, and once again, Bob Harras spends some time on his sub-plots. Crystal and Quicksilver possibly reconciling? Black Knight angsting over it and then falling into Sersi's arms? This stuff is gold! Add to that some fallout from "Galactic Storm" and an effective use of the all-too-often neglected Starjammers (seriously; Black Knight vs. Raza in a swordfight in an inspired idea), and, at the risk of repeating myself, you have another winner.
Hopefully I'm not starting to sound like a broken record at this point. It's just that this is a style (and era) of comic book writing that I really respond too. And when the artwork can equal that melodramatic soap opera, well -- I'm in comic book heaven. I can't believe I never read this run all the way through sooner.
I'm only sad Black Knight is dead now. The rest of this run just won't be the same without him.
This issue also contained a flipbook reprint of issue #53, which is the second part of a late 1960s crossover with the X-Men. The choice of issue was queried in a subsequent letters page with the response that #1 was being held back for a Marvel Milestone edition in the following thirtieth anniversary year and the issue chosen was supposedly of relevance to the current plot, though this would suggest it was ordered before the final scripting as it's not the most relevant of reprints.
ReplyDelete(The format was repeated again a few months later for Thor #450 which included a reprint of the strip from Journey into Mystery #85 featuring the debut of Loki. Thor's own debut in #83 had been recently reprinted in #432.)
I forget if it's actually stated in the comics or just the letters page but IIRC Hercules's beard was shaved because Thor was now sporting one and Hercules (either Harras or Epting) felt having two gods with beards was wrong. (There was also a bit a trend against beards in real life in the 1990s but I don't know if it had started this early.) Hercules has a bit of a history of shaving and regrowing and had been clean shaven back in the #50s though he's not in the issue reprinted here.
The back-up story demonstrates some of the problems the big events in this era ran into when they clashed with strong interlinked continuity and changing line-ups in individual titles resulting in anyone trying to assemble an overall chronology really struggling. Although Avengers doesn't have any Infinity War tie-ins, Captain America #408, Quasar #38-40 and Wonder Man #13-14 all do which would place the War after Galactic Storm.
Thanks for the info about Hercules' beard, Tim. I can confirm that it never comes up in-story, so it must have been a letters page thing.
DeleteBob Harras seems to be anti-facial hair in general, aside from stubble (which he himself frequently sported in the 90s, based on some photos accompanying promotional articles reprinted in the Omnibus collecting these issues). Kurt Busiek has said that Harras wanted Tony Stark to be clean-shaven when he came back to the Marvel Universe in the "Heroes Return" era, because mustaches were out of style. But Busiek and Tom Brevoort, both bearded, convinced Harras to allow Tony the goatee which has become his trademark appearance ever since.
I didn’t so much dislike this one as find it awfully slight, various extras notwithstanding, just based on that cover and the milestone number. Double-sized 350th issue! The Black Knight fights Raza of the Starjammers! Jarvis gets Marilla to leave him alone!
ReplyDeleteThis becomes a trend, Blam, as this run goes along. Part of the problem is that Marvel did so many of these double-sized anniversary issues at the time. 1993, the Avengers' thirtieth anniversary, will feature four double-sized, foil enhanced issues! And one or two feel special, but the others are just normal chapters in the ongoing narrative that happen to have fancy covers.
DeleteAs far as this one goes specifically, I agree... as much as I enjoyed it on its own merits, the Avengers versus the Starjammers -- or really, just Black Knight versus Raza -- doesn't exactly feel like a great hook for a giant-sized 350th issue. And it's compounded when the next issue concludes the story with some astoundingly sub-par fill-in artwork.
Apparently I got signed out of Blogger somehow. Those two Anonymous responses above are, of course, me.
ReplyDeleteOh no, Black Knight is dead!
ReplyDeleteAnyway...
It is indeed strange to see so many subplots that are integral and important to the X-Men cropping up in an "anniversary" issue of the Avengers, at least from a distance. Back then, the X-Men were everywhere and a sales magnet, so it makes sense that they'd prop up every title possible, especially one written by Harras.
Which makes it hilarious that I, a colossal X-Men fan who was buying the entire line at the time, had no idea this happened until I read this review. The post-Stern era of the Avengers must have really soured me on the book!
This comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
Delete(Posting again with the correct link.)
DeleteIt seems you weren't the only one. Avengers is notable as a title that didn't have a huge sales spike in the early 1990s and generally plodded along with a loyal but not really growing readership, albeit with a sudden drop in 1995 that was partially reversed the following year:
https://www.comichron.com/titlespotlights/avengers.html
(And before everyone says the Crossing drove readers away and then many came back to look at the Heroes Return car crash, the statements were published a little too early for either effect to have reached the annual figures. I suspect the 1995 figure may be a mess, not least due to Marvel's attempt at direct distribution.)