NOTE

Monday, February 27, 2023

AVENGERS #355

"WHEN COME THE GATHERERS...!"
Writer: Bob Harras | Penciler: Steve Epting | Letterer: Bill Oakley
Editor: Ralph Macchio | Editor-in-Chief: Tom DeFalco
join in congratulating Tom Palmer on his 100th issue
embellishing the adventures of the mighty Avengers!

The Plot: On another version of Earth, Swordsman, Magdalene, and their teammates, the Gatherers -- Cassandra and Sloth -- appear in a ruined New York just as Captain America dies outside Avengers Mansion. The Gatherers find more dead Avengers and one final living soul on Earth -- T'Challa, the Coal Tiger. The Gatherers return with the Tiger to Proctor.

On the real Earth, Black Knight has found matching energy signatures between Marissa Darrow's apartment, the Avengers emergency systems, and the skycar -- proving that someone has been in all three places. The Knight and Vision have prepared a countermeasure for further such tampering, and Black Widow orders them to implement it immediately. Meanwhile, Proctor stabilizes the dying Coal Tiger, then orders the Gatherers to Avengers Mansion to find his counterpart in the main dimension. The Gatherers teleport into the mansion at night, but are confronted by the Avengers, alerted by Black Knight's new system.

A battle breaks out, but the Gatherers prove too much for the Avengers to handle. The heroes are defeated, but left alive per Proctor's order. The Gatherers get the information they needed and depart for Wakanda to find T'Challa, the Black Panther.

Continuity Notes: There are a handful of footnotes in this one, though most point to the same pair of issues. First, we're reminded that Marissa Darrow was Magdalene's counterpart in the Avengers' dimension, per issue 348. We're then told that the Gatherers infiltrated Avengers Mansion, unknown to Avengers and readers alike, prior to the events of issues 344 (in order to override the alert system and stage a fake call from the Human Torch) and 348 (to sabotage the skycar). Hercules then tells Magdalene he will avenge his defeat at her hands in issue 344, and two pages later, Swordsman recalls his duel with the Black Knight in that same issue yet again.

We are allowed a brief glimpse of Proctor alone, as he examines an image of Sersi under the filename "Alpha/Omega", and it is revealed that he somehow knew her in the past.
Sersi is visited by Sprite of the Eternals, at the command of Sersi's sister, Thena, who is concerned over Sersi's melding with an alien Uni-Mind (which happened during "The Collection Obsession", though there's no footnote here). Sersi brushes off Thena's concern and goes on her way. Sersi also debuts a new costume this issue, stating that she "never" thought green was her color -- which seems odd, since she had been wearing green for centuries or more at this point!
Crystal speaks with Black Knight about his recently avoiding her, and he nearly tells her how he feels until Sersi arrives. Crystal leaves the two, and Sersi immediately comes on to the Knight again, as Crystal watches forlonrly.
Proctor reveals the power to read minds (or perhaps memories). It's unclear at this point if there are any limitations on the ability, as he is only shown using it on Coal Tiger (though it does appear in the scene that he needs to touch the subject in order to get anything from them).
Hercules wants to ask Taylor Madison out on a date, but can't bring himself to pick up the phone, so infatuated is he with her. So Black Widow makes the call instead, inviting Taylor to a cocktail party. It's a nice scene showing the Widow as more than a cold spy, and also highlighting a bit of a friendship between her and Hercules. I wonder if Harras was thinking of their time as teammates in the Champions when he wrote the scene?
Assemble: As usual, the answer is no. But here's a sweet group shot to make up for it:

Oh, I didn't mention Thor is in this issue too? It's kind of weird to see how Harras handles him in these issues... he's basically a non-entity, showing up for meetings and fights, but otherwise standing on the sidelines and barely talking. I suppose it's because he can't get too integrated into any of the sub-plots since he has his own ongoing series. In fact, in the above image, he's the only character present with that distinction!

Anyway -- "Avengers Assemble!" count: 4 in 22 issues to date.

My Thoughts: I love how Harras is dripping out little bits and pieces of his storyline here... we met Swordsman, Magdalene, and Proctor nearly a dozen issues ago in their first enigmatic attack. Now we learn a bit more about them -- Proctor's mysterious history with Sersi, their mission of apparently rescuing sole survivors from various doomed universes. Then there's Sersi -- her meld with the Brethren's Uni-Mind seemed a simple trick to resolve Harras's inaugural -- and otherwise totally stand-alone -- storyline, but here we learn, via Sprite, that there may be lasting effects from that moment -- which is likely meant to explain Sersi's recent bloodlust in "Galactic Storm".

It's kinda funny, when you stop to think about it: Bob Harras was the X-MEN editor and the AVENGERS writer. Both series feel sort of similar at this point in time, with regards to dripping out bits and pieces of storylines, setting up mysteries, and so forth. But what fascinates me is that Harras is clearly writing AVENGERS with an endgame in mind. I mean, I know via hindsight that the "Gathering" stoyrline will culminate in issue 375, and that all the stuff about Proctor, Sersi, etc. will be resolved. But even if I didn't know that -- this stuff feels way better conceived and thought-out than what readers would get in X-MEN over the same span of time.
It's just really interesting to me that Harras the writer was capable of planning a long-term storyline through to its definitive end, but Harras the editor was content to let his writers drop hints and set up plots willy-nilly, with no resolution planned for half of them!

Anyway -- we've yet another solid, engrossing chapter on our hands, here. I honestly feel that at this point in time, the Bob Harras/Steve Epting/Tom Palmer team can do no wrong. They're firing on all cylinders, and this run is shaping up to become all I had hoped it might be.

7 comments:

  1. Solid issue. The creative team had really clicked into place now and this was the best the book had been in years for me. I'd forgotten Thor was still there too!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. As Tim says below, don't get too attached to Thor! I believe next issue is his final appearance in the title for close to two years -- and when he returns, it's not Thor himself, but Eric Masterson as Thunderstrike (and again, he does very little of substance before abruptly vanishing once more).

      But yes, I agree -- things are running quite smoothly at this point. When I was reading these issues for this series of posts, I didn't want to put them down. I'd finish one and want to immediately go into the next without stopping to write a post. This run may have set a record for the fastest I've ever read through an extended chunk of issues for the blog.

      Delete
  2. Thor is about to disappear because of events in his own series (this issue came out the same month as Thor #452 - the two books did their twice monthlies in different months hence the numbers were briefly not in their usual #100 sync) that include a continuous story over about eleven issues that will climax in the return of the original Thor and Eric becoming Thunderstrike. As Tom DeFalco was co-writing Thor it's likely Harras was aware that this particular one was not going to be around for long.

    The Coal Tiger uses the name and costume from a Jack Kirby early concept drawing for what became the Black Panther, a nice nod to his origins.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Tim and Blam, for the info on Coal Tiger! It's funny; in retrospect I suddenly realize that I knew this. But I had long, long since forgotten when I read these issues, and nothing in them jogged my memory. But looking at Blam's link, I realize now that I've seen that Kirby concept illustration before. Probably way back when I was a kid.

      Delete

  3. Dane kissing Sersi while looking at Crystal is just weird and creepy.

    // Sersi also debuts a new costume this issue //

    We now have Dane, Crystal, Sersi, and Natasha all wearing the bomber jackets. I’m flabbergasted that Epting would add such tricky material when so much of the appeal of superheroes is that they’re basically naked figures with lines. Of course professionals need to be able to draw plain old clothing and buildings and cars, but in my experience the entry point for the vast majority of traditional comic-book artists is the costumed human form and stuff like jackets with their creases and pulls is a lot more work.

    // I wonder if Harras was thinking of their time as teammates in the Champions when he wrote the scene //

    Herc and Natasha also show up together as former/reserve Avengers in #173, whose cover spotlighting them and Yellowjacket is etched into my mind as one of the few issues of the series I got during the couple of years betwixt my first and second periods of regularly picking it up, shortly after Champions folded.

    (Since I’m linking: I also found a scan of that early Kirby drawing of Coal Tiger as presented in Jungle Action #10 online.)

    // but Harras the editor was content to let his writers drop hints and set up plots willy-nilly, with no resolution planned for half of them //

    Which is either good editing in terms of not imposing his own storytelling approach on them or bad editing in terms of, you know, not ensuring that they had at least a general endgame for plots that called for such a thing. I’m not taking a position either way.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Here's the URL for that page from Jungle Action #10: https://d3nvbf5pqk2vjh.cloudfront.net/cgccomics/monthly_2019_01/RCO031.thumb.jpg.489cc6f007929e0387cad552e81e384c.jpg

      Delete
    2. I've wondered for years exactly whose idea the bomber jackets might have been. I would be inclined to think Epting, as the artist, but for the fact that Jim Lee introduced X-Men bomber jackets a year or so earlier, most obviously and notably as part of Rogue's regular costume, but also as a rare alternate look for Cyclops as well. Which has had me occasionally wonder if Harras liked them and asked Epting to include them.

      But when I read "Galactic Storm", I noted that Sersi and Crystal and suddenly, totally randomly wearing the jackets on Hala when they didn't have them previously, with dialogue stating that Sersi conjured them. And due to that, I've since assumed that it was indeed Epting's whim, with Harras covering for him in the script.

      But who knows? Per some "extras" from the era reprtinted in the GATHERING OMNIBUS, Harras and Epting worked very closely together on this run. It seems like perhaps the old Marvel tradition of the writer and penciler co-plotting, even if the penciler did not receive a credit as such (though for the record, after a while, the credits begin reading "A Harras/Epting/Palmer Production" more often than crediting Harras and Epting separately -- but that doesn't become the case for around another year or so).

      Anyway, as with so many other things done "Marvel style", in the end it's hard to tell what was who's idea!

      As far as Harras's editing style vs. his writing style, I don't really take sides either way myself, though I do find it interesting that he was known as a very "hands-on" editor, to the point that his style was part of the reason Chris Claremont eventually threw up his hands and left Marvel. But at the same time, I don't think he was dictating stories to Claremont; rather he was just telling Claremont to give Jim Lee more power over the stories.

      He did, however dictate the annual events to the X-Writers, to the extent that, I believe, he was heavily involved in plotting them and telling the writers in some cases what needed to happen and how certain plot points should resolve.

      Meanwhile, here he's writing under Ralph Macchio, who I have long understood to be almost Harras's polar opposite -- an extremely "hands-off" editor. There as a sounding board, but not there to dictate story content in any way. And it seems Harras the writer thrives under an editor who does not share his own editorial philosophy!

      (Though going back to my thought above, Epting may share some credit for that as well, if he was indeed co-plotting as I suspect. Harras's stories feel a bit less focused during the post-375 issues, after Epting is gone. Often still good, but not as mapped out.)

      Delete